The Restless Heart: Why We Can't Stop Asking About God
December 2025
Late at night, when the noise of the day has thinned, the world feels different. A scientist studies an image of a distant galaxy. A widow sits beside an empty chair. A child asks where he was before he was born. A person who does not believe in God whispers into the silence, unsure who she is speaking to or why the impulse is there at all.
We have split the atom, mapped the genome, and photographed black holes. We have explained thunder, lightning, disease, and death. We have reduced the cosmos to equations and the mind to neurons firing in patterned ways.
And yet, in the most secular age in history, the question refuses to disappear.
Is there something more?
Not only among the faithful. Among the uncertain. Among people who do not believe yet still wonder if love is more than chemistry, if beauty points beyond the visible world, if conscience is more than social conditioning, if the longing for transcendence is something other than evolutionary residue.
If the world is only material, why is the hunger for meaning so persistent?
If the question is irrelevant, why does it keep returning?
If God is a fiction, why do we struggle to outgrow the question?
Perhaps the place to begin is not with the arguments, but with the endurance of the question itself.
What Great Minds Could Not Ignore
Across history, some of the most serious thinkers have wrestled with the ache beneath the surface of things. They did not come to faith through fear or superstition or tribal loyalty. They came because they encountered something they could not dismiss. Not a proof, but a recognition.
They were moved not by arguments alone but by what reality refused to let them ignore.
Augustine: The Restless Heart
Augustine sought fulfillment everywhere: philosophy, rhetoric, acclaim, relationships, spiritual movements. None of it quieted him. He described the longing as a wound that refused to heal.
He later wrote the line that has echoed across centuries:
“Our hearts are restless until they rest in You.”
He did not deduce this; he discovered it through exhaustion. The restlessness itself became a kind of evidence.
Pascal: Terror and Wonder
Blaise Pascal looked at the stars and felt fear.
“The eternal silence of these infinite spaces terrifies me.”
He refused to dismiss the terror as imagination. The vastness, the loneliness, the sense of disproportion between who we are and who we feel we should be pointed toward something logic alone could not contain.
His fear and wonder became a form of spiritual awareness.
C. S. Lewis: The Argument from Joy
Lewis described sudden moments of piercing longing. A melody. A scent. A childhood memory. These flashes filled him with desire for something he could not name.
“If I find in myself a desire which no experience in this world can satisfy,” he wrote, “the most probable explanation is that I was made for another world.”
For Lewis, joy was not escapism. It was a clue.
Simone Weil: Beauty as Intrusion
Simone Weil believed beauty was not decoration but disclosure. Beauty carried a weight that exceeded the material world. It was attention turned into prayer, an ordinary moment revealing something beyond itself.
Alan Lightman: The Physicist in the Boat
MIT physicist Alan Lightman calls himself an atheist. Yet one night, drifting off the coast of Maine and staring at the stars, something happened.
The boat dissolved. The boundary of his body faded. He felt an overwhelming connection to the stars, as if he were part of them. He later wrote that even if every neuron were mapped, the experience would not be fully explained.
Lightman remains an atheist, but he calls the moment a form of spiritual awareness. Even for those who reject religion entirely, the longing persists. The question refuses to die.
What We Struggle to Explain Away
The thinkers above did not share doctrines or worldviews. What they shared was recognition. They encountered something that felt more real than the explanations meant to contain it.
Longing
We hunger for meaning, beauty, justice, and love. Survival does not require symphonies, self-sacrifice, or poetry. Yet these impulses endure.
Conscience
The sense of “ought” feels revealed, not invented. It has an authority that preference cannot explain.
Beauty
Beauty arrives like a messenger. A sunset. A line of music. The face of someone we love. It awakens a hope we did not know we were missing.
Love
Not attraction or mutual benefit. Love that gives itself away. Love that recognizes infinite worth. Material explanations can describe love’s mechanics, but not its meaning.
The Persistence of the Question
If the world were only material, the hunger for meaning would not be this stubborn. The question would have died long ago. Yet it survives every cultural shift.
The question has outlived empires, ideologies, and every attempt to silence it.
Not Proofs but Signposts
You cannot weigh longing, graph beauty, or measure love. Yet these experiences feel real and refuse to be flattened.
Maybe they are not proofs. Maybe they are signposts.
Echoes.
Breadcrumbs.
Not conclusions. Invitations.
Doubt as Companion, Not Opponent
None of these thinkers lived without doubt.
Augustine questioned for years.
Pascal wrestled with silence.
Weil lived between desire and distance.
Lewis admitted faith often felt fragile.
Lightman remains an atheist who experiences transcendence.
They did not chase certainty. They lived with tension.
Doubt did not erase longing.
Longing did not erase doubt.
If God were obvious, faith would not exist.
If God were absent, the question would not survive.
What the Question Asks of Us
If the question persists, then it cannot be trivial.
It asks us to pay attention.
To beauty we did not earn.
To conscience we did not create.
To love that exceeds calculation.
To longing that refuses to settle.
To the moments when the world feels too fragile and too luminous to be an accident.
The question does not demand certainty.
It demands honesty.
The Proof Is the Question
The thinkers above did not arrive at belief through a single argument. They were drawn by the shape of reality: the way truth, beauty, goodness, and longing converge.
Maybe the proof of God is not a theorem.
Maybe it is the question itself, the one we cannot silence, the one that rises unbidden in moments of beauty, grief, wonder, and love.
We do not need certainty to feel the pull.
We only need honesty.
The question persists because something in reality keeps calling to us. Because the hunger for meaning is written into human experience. Because even in our most secular moment, we sense that we are made for more than what we can see.
Perhaps the truest question is not “Can we prove God exists?”
Perhaps it is, “Why can’t we stop asking?”
And maybe the asking is the beginning of the answer.
The longing is the evidence. The restlessness is the proof.
If you have felt this restlessness, I would be grateful to hear from you. What longing refuses to leave you alone? What questions do you carry? Reply to this message and tell me.
Selected References
Augustine, Confessions
Blaise Pascal, Pensées
C. S. Lewis, Mere Christianity; The Weight of Glory
Simone Weil, Gravity and Grace
Alan Lightman, Searching for Stars on an Island in Maine
Charles Taylor, A Secular Age
I'm new here on Substack and looking forward to any comments. Let me know your thoughts!